Friendly Atheist by @hemantmehta » Atheist Math and Imaginary Numbers


Atheist Math and Imaginary Numbers


Scikidus had the idea for the image, and I’m just throwing out some other versions:







I *so* know how I’m teaching imaginary numbers to my classes this year.

(via To Whom I May Concern)

Post to Twitter Post to Digg Post to Facebook Post to Reddit Post to StumbleUpon



15 Responses

  1. avatar Pete Says:

    That’s so clever!

  2. avatar Tim Says:

    here’s a proof i stole and adopted to my own purposes.

    suppose x=god
    x=god

    multiply by god
    x*god=god*god

    subtract x*x
    x*god-x*x=god*god-x*x

    factor
    x(x-god)=(god+x)(god-x)

    divide by (god-x)
    x=god+x

    subtract x
    0=god or god=0

    therefore god does not exist

  3. avatar Milena Says:

    Lol, math humour’s the best.

  4. avatar Jason Says:

    Except imaginary numbers are, in fact, useful.

  5. avatar Rat Bastard Says:

    @ Tim: Ah, yes, the old “divide by zero” trick. The theists try that, too. They should leave “god” in the numerator of multiplication problems, only. And I’ve seen it where the “imaginary” numbers were used against atheists. Nice trick! Some of them must be electrical engineers working on the power distribution grid. Take the electrical power feed away from any theist who doesn’t “believe in” imaginary numbers! Rotten fish and moldy bread result….

  6. avatar efrique Says:

    Is it:
    i are the square root of -1″,
    i am the square root of -1″, or
    i am that i am the square root of -1″?

  7. avatar Justin Says:

    @Tim Can one plug anything into that equation? Landlords? Ex-girlfriends? Tiny yipping dogs who won’t shut up in the night when I’m needing to get up for work the next day?

    Hmm. Let x=flufftard…

  8. avatar hoverFrog Says:

    Can you also represent the square root of god as a fraction? No, that would be irrational.

    Proof that god is not perfect.
    God is indivisible. yet, in order to be perfect God would need to be the sum of its proper positive divisors.

  9. avatar Moth Says:

    I just noticed tonight that Planet Atheist often aggregates the recent blog posts in groups of 66 (# of books in the Bible).

  10. avatar Bill Says:

    I’m reminded of a piece Azimov wrote about
    trying to convince one of his teachers that
    1/2 is no less “imaginary” (in the ordinary
    everyday sense of the word) than i.
    He challenged the teacher to give him half
    a piece of chalk. The teacher promptly
    broke a piece of chalk in two and handed
    Azimov one of the two pieces. 8-)

  11. avatar Freak Says:

    “The Imaginary That Isn’t”, The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction, March 1961. Reprinted in Asimov on Numbers.

    The teacher asked Asimov to hand him sqrt(-1) pieces of chalk. Asimov made the above challenge in reply.

  12. avatar Brian S. Says:

    What exactly does the modulus of a purely imaginary god tell us?

  13. avatar Ian Says:

    Wouldn’t teaching this in class be hypocritical and also potentially a violation of the First Amendment (although atheism =/= religion, I could foresee arguments).

    Not that I thought you were serious.

  14. avatar Pseudonym Says:

    OK, I’m confused. Obviously this is not saying that God is pure imaginary, because the complex numbers are not an ordered field, and hence less-than doesn’t make sense.

    So what’s it actually saying?

    Surely not that God is timelike rather than to spacelike. This has interesting theological implications, but most people who write on the topic seem to agree that God is not bound by spacetime.

  15. avatar scikidus Says:

    I like the new versions. I just thought this up a few days ago, and thought it would be nice to share it with the world. I didn’t think it would be noticed so quickly!

    Actually, some of the comments in this thread have given me another idea. To Photoshop!

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.

Subscribe without commenting

© Copyright Friendly Atheist by @hemantmehta 2009. All rights reserved. | Powered by Wordpress | Designed by Elegant WPT